Sunlit cream-stucco home entrance with shell-limestone steps, a pale concrete garden walk, coconut palm and flowering plumeria.

Anna Maria City Pier Reopening: What's Changing on Arrival

  • October 22, 2026

"We're way up here at the north end of the island, you know, so people wanna have a reason to come all the way up here," Cool Beans owner Morgan Bryant told WWSB in August. For about two years, the north end has been missing that reason. The Anna Maria City Pier has been part of the island since 1911, and it has been closed since Hurricanes Helene and Milton.

The reason is almost back. City officials expect the pier and its new restaurant to be fully open before the end of the year, and the operators are aiming for November. The pier that reopens won't be connected to the rest of the island the way the old one was, though. The ferry stop that once brought visitors in by water isn't expected back until 2028. Until then, the pier will be a place you reach by land, and the free trolley, Pine Avenue and a parking plan that hasn't been settled yet will decide how that works.

The pier coming back has more room at the T-end

Most of the rebuilt structure is finished. The new walkway is complete, and Holmes Beach City Commissioner Carol Whitmore told WWSB the new pilings went in "50 feet deeper, I hear," compared with the patch job after Hurricane Irma in 2017. On Sept. 8, the Anna Maria City Commission authorized Mayor Mark Short to sign a $436,192 contract with Sarasota-based Southern Cross Contracting for what Short called "the finishing work at the T-end of the pier." That includes new public restrooms, roll-up doors, and hurricane-rated shutters to protect those doors, The Anna Maria Island Sun reported.

The two buildings at the end of the pier are being split up differently this time. Mote Marine is not returning. GSM Partners, the group of Brian Seymour, Ben Sato and Jason Sato, signed a five-year lease in June to run PIERadise. It will use the larger former Mote building for dining, drinks and fishing, and the smaller former City Pier Grill building for its kitchen and bait shop. Seymour ran the City Pier Grill before the storms, and he told WWSB the old setup was "kind of an upgraded snack shack with no real indoor cover from the weather."

Several details of the lease matter for anyone who just wants to walk out and fish. Under the terms the Sun reported in June, the pier's common areas and PIERadise keep the same hours, 7 a.m. to 10 p.m., seven days a week. All of the T-end seating except the bar seats is open to anyone, whether or not they're customers. Seymour said bait and tackle will return, and fishing will stay allowed around the same T-end footprint. He also told WWSB that PIERadise plans daily entertainment from local musicians.

At the Sept. 8 meeting, Seymour said his group was ready to move in once given the green light and hoped to open in November.

The open-air seating was built for ferry riders who won't arrive until 2028

The roll-up doors open onto shared seating meant for three groups: PIERadise customers, people visiting the pier, and Gulf Islands Ferry passengers. The ferry passengers are included "if and when ferry service returns to the City Pier," in the Sun's words.

That return is further away than the pier's reopening. Ferry service to Anna Maria was suspended in October 2024 after Hurricane Milton destroyed the walkway, and the Sun reported on Sept. 8 that it isn't expected to resume until 2028. When the lease was awarded in June, a county-funded ferry landing next to the pier was described as a 2027 or 2028 project, and the city and county were still discussing it.

Meanwhile, the ferry has grown at the other end of the island. On Sept. 2, Manatee County's Gulf Islands Ferry made its first official run to a new stop at the Bayside South Boat Ramp, across the street from Coquina Beach. Here is how the route works now:

  • The Manatee Belle runs between the Bradenton Riverwalk Pier and the Historic Bridge Street Pier, a trip of about 50 minutes. It holds 91 passengers and has an air-conditioned cabin and a restroom.
  • The smaller pontoon ferries, including the Downtown Duchess, connect Bridge Street with the Coquina stop in under 15 minutes.

For now, a ride over from Bradenton ends in Bradenton Beach, about as far from the City Pier as you can get on this island. Operating days have been listed differently by different sources, so check the ferry's own schedule page before planning a trip around it.

So the trolley and Pine Avenue carry the load

With no boat landing at the pier, the free Anna Maria Island Trolley becomes the main way to get there without a car. Manatee County lists Route 5 running between the City Pier and Coquina Beach along Gulf Drive every 20 minutes, from 6 a.m. to 10:30 p.m., seven days a week. That route runs between the two ends that will matter this winter: the reopened pier in the north and the new ferry stop at Coquina in the south. Someone could take the Manatee Belle to Bridge Street, catch the trolley north, and finish at PIERadise without ever parking.

Driving is less certain. At a parking study meeting on Aug. 31, the city's future plan for its own spaces near the pier and City Pier Park was still undecided, including whether they would be free, timed or paid, according to the Sun. The same report described a proposal for free parking on Pine Avenue with an enforced three-hour limit, and noted that this was still only a proposal.

Here is where each piece stands as of mid-October:

Piece of the north end Status Most recent update
City Pier walkway Complete Sept. 16, 2026
T-end buildings and restrooms Final-phase contract approved Sept. 8, 2026
PIERadise Operators aiming for November Sept. 8, 2026
Ferry stop at City Pier Not expected until 2028 Sept. 8, 2026
Parking near the pier Undecided Aug. 31, 2026 meeting
Rod & Reel Pier Still awaiting a rebuild May 26, 2026

The north end's other pier is still running from Holmes Beach

The City Pier's return leaves the Rod & Reel Pier's absence easier to see. The Rod & Reel was part of Anna Maria Island for more than 75 years. Helene damaged it, and Milton, in owner Oliver Lemke's words, "finished what Helene had started." WWSB reported in May that Lemke's GoFundMe had raised $104,431 toward a $300,000 goal from nearly 1,000 donations, and that there is no insurance coverage or major investor behind the rebuild.

The kitchen kept going on land. The Rod & Reel restaurant opened on Nov. 21, 2025, at 3246 East Bay Drive in Holmes Beach. It has 60 seats, a menu close to the pier's old one, the pier's original sign, and engraved planks recovered from the debris. Video screens under those planks show live footage of what's left of the pier and Tampa Bay. Lemke told the Sun that "the money you spend here is going toward the rebuild of the pier." The restaurant's own site currently lists daily hours of 11 a.m. to 9 p.m., later than the 8 a.m. opening when it launched.

Other long closures have ended one at a time. Beach Bistro, at 6600 Gulf Drive in Holmes Beach, reopened in late September after two years closed because of Helene damage, the Herald-Tribune reported. The City Pier would be the next big one, and the Rod & Reel is the one still without a date.

Pine Avenue's calendar runs ahead of the pier

The blocks between Gulf Drive and the pier already have a fall and winter schedule, whatever date PIERadise picks:

  1. Tuesdays, 9 a.m. to 2 p.m., through April. The Anna Maria Community Farmers Market at Roser Church, 512 Pine Ave., a short walk from the pier's entrance.
  2. Friday, Oct. 30, 6 to 8 p.m. Island Trunk or Treat at The Center of Anna Maria Island.
  3. Saturday, Nov. 14, 9 a.m. to 2 p.m. The Roser Holiday Market, back after a two-year break. The Center's beach cleanup runs the same morning from 9 to 11 a.m.
  4. Saturday, Dec. 5, 10:30 a.m. to 2 p.m. The 25th Annual Lester Family Fun Day at The Center.
  5. Saturday, Dec. 12, 9 to 11 a.m. Another beach cleanup with The Center.

If PIERadise opens in November as its operators hope, the Nov. 14 Holiday Market could be the first busy Saturday when Roser Church and a working City Pier draw crowds to the same end of Pine Avenue. Parking may still be undecided then, so the trolley's last north stop is the easier way to arrive.

If you own a home near Pine Avenue or anywhere on the north end and want to know how the pier's reopening, the delayed ferry stop and the parking decision might affect your property, Stephanie Seacat can walk you through it with local, on-the-ground context. Start with a quick request to Get Your Home Valuation, and we'll keep an eye on the pier for you.

Work With Stephanie

Her passion for the real estate industry thrives and is committed to nurturing long-term relationships and providing an exceptional real estate experience for buyers, sellers, and investors to see your dreams of living the luxury, lifestyle in paradise become a reality.

Follow Stephanie on Instagram